Feeding a Resonant Dipole With 600 Ω Open‑Wire
— Why No Choke Is Needed, and How Line Length Really Matters
A precise, monoband-focused guide with a short contrast to the multiband “doublet”.
TL;DR
- A center-fed resonant dipole and 600 Ω open-wire are both balanced; with symmetric geometry, feed it directly — no feedpoint choke required.
- Za (antenna) and Z0 (line) are independent; mismatch creates SWR on the line, not extra radiation. With low-loss open-wire, efficiency stays high even with significant SWR.
- Near-field geometry dominates: keep the first 0.1–0.2 λ of feedline orthogonal to the dipole and clear of conductive surfaces; then route as needed.
- For monoband with no tuner, put a 1:1 current balun at the base, then short 50 Ω coax to the shack. Avoid odd ¼-wave line lengths and aim for an electrical ½-wave so the coax SWR is modest (~1.4:1 typical).
Why No Choke Is Needed at the Feedpoint
A coax-fed dipole often needs a choke because the coax shield is an unbalanced conductor and can carry stray return currents. An open-wire line is balanced: the two conductors carry equal and opposite currents so their fields cancel and the line does not radiate when the geometry is symmetric.
- Make both dipole legs the same electrical length and height.
- Let both conductors leave the feedpoint together, at right angles to the dipole for the first 0.1–0.2 λ.
- Keep that early run in free air, several line spacings away from metal and wet surfaces.
Small asymmetries can still induce a little stray return current on the line. That’s why we put a 1:1 current balun at the bottom—it scrubs any residual current before the coax.
Antenna Impedance vs. Line Impedance — Two Different Things
Quantity | Meaning | Typical value |
---|---|---|
Antenna feedpoint impedance (Za) | Electrical load at the dipole center (resonant) | ~70 Ω (flat-top in free space); often 40–60 Ω for inverted-V |
Feedline characteristic impedance (Z0) | Ratio of V/I for a traveling wave on the line | Common: ~300–500 Ω (homebrew), ~600 Ω (wide-spaced open-wire) |
They don’t have to match. If Za ≠ Z0
, you get SWR on the line, but with low-loss open-wire this adds only a small fraction of a dB for typical HF lengths. The energy still flows efficiently from antenna to your balun/coax.
Why Line Length Matters
Coupling & Balance (Does the Line Radiate?)
The reactive near field of a thin half-wave dipole extends to roughly ~0.2 λ. If the feedline leaves at right angles and stays clear for the first 0.1–0.2 λ, differential currents dominate and the line remains “quiet.” This is a geometry problem—not a magic cutoff length.
Impedance Transformation (What the Balun/Coax Sees)
The input impedance of a transmission line is length-dependent:
Zin = Z0 · ( ZL + j Z0 tan βℓ ) / ( Z0 + j ZL tan βℓ )
- At ¼ λ, impedance inverts (high ↔ low).
- At ½ λ, impedance repeats (
Zin ≈ ZL
).
Line length | Zin at bottom | 50 Ω coax SWR |
---|---|---|
0.00 λ | 70 + j0 Ω | 1.4 : 1 |
0.125 λ | 138 + j 584 Ω | ≈ 52 : 1 |
0.25 λ | ≈ 5.14 kΩ (resistive) | ≈ 103 : 1 |
0.375 λ | 138 − j 584 Ω | ≈ 52 : 1 |
0.50 λ | 70 + j0 Ω | 1.4 : 1 |
Practical takeaway: For monoband into a 1:1 balun then coax with no tuner, avoid odd ¼-wave feedline lengths and aim for an electrical ½-wave (or any integer multiple). Staying within roughly ±2 % of ½-wave typically keeps coax SWR ≤ 2:1.
Practical Build for a Lightweight Monoband Dipole
- Antenna: Center-fed resonant dipole or inverted-V (e.g., 40 m or 20 m).
- Feedline: True wide-spaced open-wire (~600 Ω) or “ladder line” (~400–500 Ω).
- Transition: 1:1 current (Guanella) balun at ground → short 50 Ω coax to the shack.
- Routing: Keep the first 0.1–0.2 λ orthogonal and clear of other conductors.
What Spacing Really Gives “600 Ω”?
For two round wires in air, Z0 ≈ 120·acosh(S/d)
, where S is spacing and d conductor diameter.
Conductor | Spacing S (mm) | Approx. Z0 (Ω) |
---|---|---|
#14 (~1.6 mm) | ≈ 120 | ≈ 600 Ω |
#12 (~2.0 mm) | ≈ 150 | ≈ 600 Ω |
#10 (~2.6 mm) | ≈ 200 | ≈ 600 Ω |
#12 @ 25–30 mm | — | ≈ 385–405 Ω (typical ladder-line) |
“450 Ω ladder line” often measures 400–500 Ω in practice.
How This Differs From a Multiband Doublet
Feature | Resonant Monoband Dipole | Multiband Doublet |
---|---|---|
Feedline | Open-wire (any Z0) | Open-wire (any Z0) |
Matching | Direct (resonant) | Requires tuner |
Balun placement | At ground, 1:1 current | At/inside tuner |
Feedpoint choke | Not needed | Not needed |
Bands | Single | Many |
Use case | Light, simple, portable | Stationary, flexible |
Design Cookbook (Monoband, No Tuner)
-
Cut the dipole for resonance near band center:
L[m] ≈ 143/f[MHz]
. - Choose feedline Z0: 400–600 Ω typical.
-
Plan open-wire length: make electrical length ≈ n·½-wave.
L½[m] ≈ (150·VF)/f
, VF≈0.98–0.99. - At the base: 1:1 balun → short 50 Ω coax. If SWR > 2:1, trim line or touch up with ATU.
- Static & weather: 100 kΩ–1 MΩ bleeder across feedpoint helps with charge.
Half-Wave Open-Wire Reference Lengths (VF = 0.99)
Band | Center (MHz) | ½-Wave Line (m) |
---|---|---|
160 m | 1.9 | ≈ 78.2 |
80 m | 3.6 | ≈ 41.3 |
40 m | 7.1 | ≈ 20.9 |
20 m | 14.2 | ≈ 10.5 |
10 m | 28.4 | ≈ 5.2 |
Troubleshooting & Gotchas
- RF in the shack: Ensure bottom balun ≥ 3 kΩ choking Z; add coax choke if needed.
- High SWR: Likely near ¼-wave length. Trim toward ½-wave.
- Rain detuning: Wet wood/leaves change Z0; keep line clear and elevated.
- Inverted-V: Lower Za (40–60 Ω). Still fine — check your ½-wave window.
- Ferrite heating: If operating near ¼-wave Z peaks, reduce power or adjust length.
Special Case: 160 m — Short Open-Wire Sections
Short answer: At 160 m, a 16 m line is only 0.10 λ, so you’re far from the ¼-wave points. SWR on the line stays constant; input impedance changes only slowly with length because phase rotation is small at 1.8–2 MHz.
-
SWR on the line is length-independent:
SWR = (1+|ΓL|)/(1−|ΓL|)
. -
Only phase changes with ℓ:
Γin=ΓL·e−j2βℓ
. - At 1.9 MHz (λ≈158 m), 16 m = 0.10 λ → rotation ~28°, far from 90° inversion.
- Consequence: Below 0.1 λ, impedance varies slowly and efficiency remains high.
- Contrast: On 80 m, same line = 0.2 λ (144° rotation); on 40 m = 0.4 λ (288° rotation).
Bottom line: A resonant monoband dipole fed with open-wire is simple and efficient. Keep the early section symmetric, avoid odd ¼-wave lengths, use a solid 1:1 current balun at the base—and enjoy clean, stable signals.
Mini-FAQ
- Do I need a choke or balun at the top? — No. Balanced antenna + balanced line = quiet line. Place the 1:1 current balun at the bottom.
- My line is 450 Ω. Does it still work? — Yes. Same principles; avoid ¼-wave, aim for ½-wave.
- Can I run without any tuner? — Yes, if your open-wire is near a ½-wave electrically (SWR ≤ 2:1).
- How close to ½-wave do I need? — ±2 % → SWR ≤ 2:1; ±3 % → ≤ 3:1.
Interested in more technical content? Subscribe to our updates for deep-dive RF articles and lab notes.
Questions or experiences to share? Contact RF.Guru.