RX Arrays: Why MMIC-Based Phasing Beats Old School Wire Wound Systems
RX Arrays: Why MMIC-Based Phasing Beats Old-School Wire-Wound
Early low-band receive arrays — inspired by ON4UN and contemporaries — used toroidal transformers, ferrite combiners, and lumped-element phasing lines. They were brilliant for their time, but modern stations ask for wideband, temperature-stable, low-noise, repeatable systems that play nicely with SDRs and digital signal processing. That’s where MMIC-based hybrids, phase shifters, and buffered combiners win decisively.
Key Advantages of Modern Phased RX Systems
1) Higher Common-Mode Rejection (CMRR)
Bifilar wire transformers accumulate parasitics (leakage L, inter-winding C) that unbalance differential paths, often limiting practical CMRR to ~20–30 dB. Laser-trimmed MMIC couplers/hybrids keep amplitude/phase symmetry tight, delivering 60–70 dB+ CMRR over HF/low-VHF in well-designed modules — a huge win for common-mode noise suppression on suburban feedlines.
2) Phase Stability vs Temperature & Frequency
Coax delay lines drift degrees with seasonal temperature swings; ferrite permeability also changes. MMIC networks on low-drift substrates (PTFE/Rogers) with tailored phase equalization can hold <1° phase error from 1.8–30 MHz, preserving null depth and pattern consistency across a contest weekend.
3) Compact, Integrated, EMI-Resistant
Multilayer controlled-impedance PCBs with ground planes and shield lids shorten paths, shrink parasitics, and reduce self-pickup. Integration of LNA buffers, filtering, and hybrids means fewer boxes, less cabling, and cleaner behavior in real-world RF noise.
4) True Wideband Without Switching
Old phasing boxes were single-band or needed relays/stubs. Modern quadrature/Lange/Wilkinson building blocks give octave-spanning coverage (typ. 1.8–54 MHz) with flat amplitude/phase, enabling simultaneous multi-band RX, diversity reception, and wideband SDR capture without reconfiguration.
5) Better Port-to-Port Isolation
Transformer combiners often manage 10–15 dB isolation; coupling between antenna ports collapses nulls. MMIC Wilkinson/Lange topologies routinely achieve 25–35 dB; with buffered LNA stages you can realize >40 dB effective isolation, protecting pattern accuracy and steering.
6) Manufacturing Repeatability
Hand-wound toroids vary unit-to-unit (mutual coupling, inter-winding C). MMIC devices are photolithographically consistent, letting multi-element arrays match predictably — critical for >30 dB calibrated nulls and repeatable field service.
7) Lower Noise, Higher Dynamic Range
Ferrite/matching networks add loss ahead of the first active device, raising noise figure. Placing low-NF MMIC LNAs at the feedpoints yields <1 dB NF and OIP3 +30 to +40 dBm (architecture-dependent), improving IMD immunity around strong AM/BC stations while maintaining sensitivity.
8) Precision Phasing & Smart Beamforming
Fixed/switched coax delays steer in coarse steps. MMIC all-pass/phase-shifter networks enable continuous trim, adaptive nulling, elevation control, and even DoA estimation for advanced SDR users. Arrays become tools, not just fixed patterns.
Practical Integration Notes
- Front-end protection: Add ESD clamps/limiters ahead of LNAs for lightning-induced pulses; choose devices with low C to preserve NF.
- Isolation strategy: Maintain galvanic isolation (1:1 UNUNs on RX paths) where feedline/common-mode coupling is suspected.
- Bias & grounding: Use star-grounding on the PCB, filtered bias tees, and RF chokes to keep DC rails quiet.
- Calibration: Provide a trim path (phase/atten) per channel; a 0.5–1.0 dB / 0.5–1.0° trim range goes a long way in the field.
Conclusion
Wire-wound phasing boxes built the foundation, but they cap performance in bandwidth, repeatability, null depth, and thermal stability. MMIC-based hybrids, phase shifters, and buffered combiners deliver deep nulls, strong CMRR, wideband coverage, and consistent manufacturing — a clear leap forward for modern contesting, weak-signal DXing, and SDR experimentation.
Mini-FAQ
- Do MMIC arrays still need 1:1 UNUNs? — Yes when common-mode is suspected. Galvanic isolation reduces shack noise ingress.
- Will MMICs survive strong AM/BC? — Choose LNAs with high OIP3 (+30 dBm or better) and add input limiters/filters.
- How wideband can I go? — Well-designed couplers/phasers cover 1.8–54 MHz with flat phase; antennas and feedlines must also be broadband.
- Is temperature drift solved? — Substrate + design choice can hold phase error <1° HF-wide; still allow trim/calibration for best nulls.
- Do I need relays for bands? — Usually no; MMIC phasing is broadband. Relays may still switch preselection filters if desired.
Interested in more technical content? Subscribe to our updates.
Questions or experiences to share? Contact RF.Guru.