Captain Radials: Why I Don’t Want an SDR Ham Radio

Captain Radials begins with a reassuring disclaimer: “I’m not anti-SDR.”

Which is always the sign that we are about to witness a calm, measured discussion where nobody will imply that digital signal processing is basically witchcraft.

He then explains, at length, that he operates from a quiet QTH, prefers stable audio, and enjoys a particular sound.

This is entirely reasonable.

It is also not a technical argument.

“I like how this radio sounds” is a preference.
“I like how this radio sounds therefore SDR is the radio deciding for you” is a small, festive hallucination.

The real comedy is that his “poster child” for analog honesty is… a Kenwood flagship.

A Kenwood. With DSP in the receive chain.

So we begin the sermon about not wanting “the radio to reinterpret the signal” while standing inside a radio that is, quietly, unapologetically doing mathematics.

The Core Claim

Captain Radials draws a tidy moral line:

• Analog rig — “Here’s reality, you decide.”
• SDR — “The radio decides what you should hear.”

This is charming, like saying a tube amp is “honest” because it distorts in a flattering way.

But it has a small flaw: analog rigs also decide things constantly.

The IF filter decides what survives. AGC decides what gets smashed. Mixers decide what gets created and what gets rejected. Nonlinearity decides what becomes intermod soup when the band is busy.

The only difference is whether the decisions are soldered in place or adjustable with a menu.

The existence of a menu does not mean you have been placed under digital tyranny.

“SDR Can’t Invent Signals”

Yes.

Neither can a toaster.

No receiver invents information that never reached the antenna.

But nobody serious buys SDR to summon phantom DX. They buy it because it makes filtering and control easier, sharper, and faster.

Noise power scales with bandwidth. If you narrow bandwidth, the noise drops. This is not magic. It’s physics.

Captain Radials treats this like a philosophical debate about honesty.

It is, unfortunately for content creation, a math problem.

The “My Brain Is the SDR” Moment

This is the peak roast material.

He explains that his ears and brain reconstruct callsigns from fragments, rhythm, cadence, and deep operator intuition.

Cool. Many experienced operators can do that.

But as advice to an audience, it reads like:

“Why use power steering? I have trained forearms.”
“Why use antibiotics? I have a strong vibe.”
“Why use DSP? I have a personal SDR inside my skull.”

Most people don’t want to operate like a human error-correcting decoder at hour three of a pileup. They want to enjoy the hobby, work stations, and not finish the evening feeling like they were forced to listen to a blender narrate Shakespeare.

DSP Fatigue (A Real Thing, Explained Incorrectly)

DSP fatigue is real. Some noise reduction settings sound watery, phasey, and uncanny.

That does not prove SDR is “deciding for you.” It proves that turning the NR knob to “Aquarium Mode” is unpleasant.

Most SDR radios let you:

• turn NR off
• use clean IF filtering only
• tune AGC behavior
• apply notches/blankers lightly

If you want stable audio, you can have stable audio. The DSP is not a mandatory subscription to suffering.

The False Conclusion

Captain Radials’ lived experience can be true: a quiet QTH can make two good receivers sound “close enough,” and operator skill can dominate the outcome.

But his conclusion is the part that misleads followers:

A preference is not a principle.
A vibe is not a specification.
And “I like my Kenwood” is not proof that SDR is a lie.

The tube-radio analogy fits perfectly: you may prefer the sound, the ergonomics, the feel… but claiming it is “more real” is mythology with a front panel.

RF.Guru Verdict

If you love a traditional superhet, keep it. If you hate heavy NR artifacts, turn them down or off. If you operate from a quiet QTH, congratulations — you are wealthy in the only currency that matters: low noise floor.

But please stop presenting SDR as “the radio deciding for you” while praising a flagship Kenwood that happily uses DSP where it makes sense.

That’s not technical education.

That’s a bedtime story… told over warm hiss… while a processor does math in the background.

Anyway.

Kettle’s on. ☕

Interested in more quiet RF heresies?
https://listmonk.rf.guru/subscription/form

Questions or experiences to share? Feel free to contact RF.Guru.